The Kettle, the Pot, the Constitution, and a Constitutional Fiction Called a “Caretaker Committee” — A Final Rejoinder to Comrade Babatunde Agunbiade

0

Comrade Babatunde Agunbiade has responded to my earlier rejoinder with a document he titled “The Kettle Calls the Pot Black.” The title is telling: if ever there was a kettle with no bottom calling a pot black, this is it.

I will not waste words on invective. I will deal with facts, law, and the documented record. And I will begin where Agunbiade ended: with his claim to be the “National Chairman” of a “Caretaker Committee” of the National Conscience Party.

1. The Caretaker Committee Is a Constitutional Fiction. Show Me the Article.

Comrade Agunbiade has publicly accepted that he leads a so-called National Caretaker Committee. I invite him, before the Nigerian public, to do one simple thing: point to the article of the NCP Constitution that provides for the creation of a Caretaker Committee.

He cannot. Because no such provision exists.

The NCP Constitution—the document that governs the party founded by Chief Gani Fawehinmi—provides for specific organs: the National Executive Committee (NEC), the National Consultative Council (NCC), the National Working Committee, and the zonal and state structures. Article 4.4.2 of the NCP Constitution addresses the procedure for filling vacancies and the circumstances under which a chairman may step aside. Nowhere—not in Article 4.4.2, not in Article 2, not in any article—is there a provision for a “Caretaker Committee.” It is a body alien to the NCP Constitution, manufactured from thin air to serve a purpose that the Constitution does not permit.

Agunbiade’s entire claim to authority rests on a document that does not exist and a procedure that the Constitution does not authorise. He is not a chairman of anything recognised by the NCP Constitution. He is the beneficiary of an illegality.

2. How Agunbiade Became “Chairman”: The Anatomy of a Constitutional Coup

Agunbiade should be honest enough to tell the public how he became the chairman of this illegal body, and by whom he was installed. Let me help him with the facts.

Mr. Agunbiade was appointed by Dr. Yunusa Tanko on 22 January 2023, at a purported National Consultative Council (NCC) meeting in Abuja. That meeting was convened by Tanko in clear violation of the NCP Constitution, which vests the power to convene such meetings in the General Secretary. It was boycotted by five out of the six National Deputy Chairmen and the General Secretary, precisely because it was unconstitutionally called and presided over by a man who was, by that date, already a public official of another political party.

At the time Tanko installed Agunbiade, two facts are indisputable. First, the NCP had been deregistered by INEC for almost three years, since February 2020. INEC deregistered the NCP and 73 other parties on 6 February 2020. Second, Tanko had publicly decamped to the Labour Party on 16 October 2022, when he sent a message to NCP leaders announcing his appointment as the Labour Party Spokesperson and describing himself as the “FACE of Peter Obi and Datti Baba-Ahmed Presidency.” From 2020, he had been acting as an Obidients spokesman for nearly two years before that announcement. A man who is a member and spokesman of the Labour Party cannot preside over an NCP meeting. A man who has left a party cannot appoint a caretaker committee for that party. The appointment is void ab initio. It is a nullity. It has no legal consequence whatsoever.

3. The Question Agunbiade Cannot Answer: Which Party Did Tanko Belong To on 22 January 2023?

Agunbiade’s defence of Tanko collapses on the anvil of a single, simple question: Which political party did Dr. Yunusa Tanko belong to on 22 January 2023?

The answer is a matter of public record. On 16 October 2022, Tanko sent a WhatsApp message to NCP leaders announcing his appointment as the Spokesperson for the Labour Party and describing himself as the “FACE of Peter Obi and Datti Baba-Ahmed Presidency.” I challenged him publicly at the time, through the pages of newspapers, that he could not be the NCP Chairman and the Labour Party Spokesman at the same time. Article 2.2 of the NCP Constitution is explicit: it is the duty of every member, especially office holders, to uphold the goals of the Party at all times, and failure to do so constitutes anti-party activity, punishable under the Constitution. Tanko’s dual role was a walking, talking act of anti-party activity. The National Deputy Chairmen of the NCP subsequently passed a vote of no confidence on him for precisely this reason—holding office in the Labour Party while claiming to chair the NCP.

Where on earth—in the Stone Age or the 21st century—does one man chair two political parties? Can Agunbiade debunk this? He cannot. On 22 January 2023, Tanko was a Labour Party man. He had no authority to preside over any NCP structure. The meeting he convened was a gathering of political squatters, not a constitutional organ of the NCP.

4. The Boycott: Conscience Refused to Be Bought

Agunbiade may not know this, but the reason five Deputy Chairmen and the General Secretary stayed away is that our conscience could not be bought with transportation fare and hotel accommodation. Tanko provided those inducements to Agunbiade and the handful of others who attended. They sold their signatures for a plate of rice and a hotel bed. We refused. That is the difference between those who built the NCP and those who are now trying to inherit it through a back door.

5. The So-Called Expulsion: Where Is the Disciplinary Process?

Agunbiade says I was expelled following “anti-party activities” in accordance with the “disciplinary position taken by the appropriate Party authority.” I challenge him: Show the disciplinary process.

Where is the query? Where is the disciplinary committee? Where is the hearing? Where is the report? Where is the decision of the NEC? The NCP Constitution does not permit expulsion by press statement or by the fiat of a self-appointed caretaker committee. On 24 January 2023, the NCP South-South Zonal Council passed a unanimous vote of confidence on me, condemning the “expulsion” as not only unconstitutional but “devoid of the principles of fair-hearing,” and explicitly identifying it as “the manipulation of Tanko Yunusa.” On 29 January 2023, the meeting of National Deputy Chairmen reaffirmed that the “removal” of Adebola Lateef and myself was “unconstitutional, null and void.” On 22 February 2023, the NCP National Coordinating Council formally rescinded the expulsion decision taken at the Abuja meeting.

Agunbiade’s claim is as hollow as the body he claims to chair. His attempt to support his master is becoming hazardous for him.

6. Tinubu, Obi, and the Question of Consistency

Agunbiade has dredged up the NCP’s February 2023 endorsement of Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu, a communiqué I signed as National Deputy Chairman (South-South). He seems to think this is a gotcha. It is not. Let me explain the difference between what I did and what Tanko did.

When the NCP endorsed Tinubu, did I or the members of the NCP with me decamp to the APC? No. I remained in the NCP. I did not take up an appointment as a spokesman for the APC. I did not chair two parties at once. The NCP made a political decision as a party, and I was part of that decision. That is politics. That is what parties do. The NCC meeting of 22 February 2023, after reviewing the candidates, unanimously agreed that Tinubu was more qualified, and expressly rejected Tanko’s purported endorsement of Obi, noting that “in pushing that decision, the leadership of the party was not consulted by the former Chairman, Mallam Tanko Yunusa.”

What Tanko did was different. He unilaterally adopted Peter Obi as the NCP’s candidate at a Kangaroo meeting, using Agunbiade and others to give credibility to an endorsement that the party’s constitutional organs had not authorised. The NCP’s lawful leadership subsequently issued a communiqué explicitly rejecting Obi as the NCP candidate and clarifying that the NCP’s preferred candidate was Tinubu, not Obi. Tanko was not speaking for the NCP. He was speaking for himself and his new Labour Party masters.

And then there is the matter of Tanko’s own record. As far back as 2011, while serving as NCP General Secretary, Tanko contested for the House of Representatives under Buhari’s Congress for Progressive Change (CPC) without resigning his NCP membership. He lost. He crawled back to the NCP. I vehemently opposed his retention as General Secretary, but Chief Femi Falana, then National Chairman, overruled me and allowed him to continue. That is the man Agunbiade is defending. Since then, Tanko has been a political nomad: from the CPC to the NCP, from the NCP to the Labour Party, from Labour to the ADC, from the ADC to the NDC, and now from the NDC to the SDP. That is five political parties. That is the “bride” Agunbiade worships.

7. Who Loves the Party? The Question of Funding and Sacrifice

Agunbiade asks: between himself, Tanko, and me, who loves the party the most?

I will answer with a question. If Agunbiade and his illegal Caretaker Committee love the NCP so much, why have they not contributed a single naira to the legal battle for the last six years?

Since INEC deregistered the NCP in 2020, I have single-handedly financed the legal challenge from the Federal High Court (Suit No. FHC/L/544/2020) through to the Court of Appeal (Appeal No. CA/LAG/CV/880/2020). Our counsel, Barrister Marcus Eyarhono, Esq., of Sui Generis Chambers, has prosecuted this case with rigour. We await judgment. If I had refused to fund this battle, would Agunbiade still be going about claiming to be the chairman of an amorphous body called a National Caretaker Committee? The answer is no. The party would have been buried. The only reason Agunbiade has a platform to issue press statements is that I kept the party alive in court. And he has the audacity to call me the kettle?

Agunbiade’s defence of Tanko is not far-fetched. He who pays the piper dictates the tune. Tanko appointed Agunbiade as his caretaker committee chairman. Agunbiade has no choice but to sing his paymaster’s song. That is why he resisted the attempt to remove Tanko’s name from the suit in court—because Tanko can no longer be called the Chairman of the NCP in the court records. The entire charade is about keeping Tanko’s name alive in the litigation so that he can crawl back to the NCP when the SDP loses in 2027. Tanko is a fair-weather friend. As long as he benefits, he sticks. Cut off the benefits, and he becomes your enemy. He supported Buhari in 2015. When Buhari failed to appoint him, he abandoned Buhari in 2019 and publicly endorsed Atiku. When Atiku lost, he turned to Obi. When Obi’s camp showed him the door, he ran to the ADC, then the NDC, and now the SDP. Agunbiade and his co-travellers ratified every one of these betrayals.

8. The Legacy of Gani Fawehinmi Is Not for Sale

Let me be clear about my purpose. The fact that God has used me to keep Gani’s legacy alive is not a licence for me to hijack the party. My goal is simple: to ensure that those who contributed to the deregistration of the NCP are not allowed to come back, because they can never be trusted with the party’s future.

Chief Gani Fawehinmi founded the NCP on the principles of integrity, justice, and selfless service. He did not found it to be a bridal train for political opportunists. He did not found it to be a vehicle for men who would chair one party while serving as spokesman for another. He did not found it to be a party where a caretaker committee could be conjured out of thin air by a man who had already left for another political camp.

Agunbiade’s “Caretaker Committee” is a constitutional nullity. His “chairmanship” is an illegality. His defence of Tanko is the defence of a paymaster by a beneficiary. And his attempt to rewrite history is an insult to the memory of Gani Fawehinmi.

The Court of Appeal will soon deliver judgment. That judgment will settle the question of the NCP’s lawful leadership. Until then, Agunbiade can issue as many press statements as his paymaster’s funds can sustain. But he should know this: the NCP is not a private company. It is not an investment portfolio. It is not a bride to be given away to the highest bidder. It is the institutional embodiment of a struggle, and that struggle will not be auctioned by men who have already sold themselves to other political masters.

Signed:

Pastor Peters Osawaru Omoragbon
National Deputy Chairman (South-South), National Conscience Party
NOV 20 2026.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *